Skip to main content

40 questions about roman catholicism -- a book review


Gregg R. Allison's 40 Questions about Roman Catholicism is another volume in Kregel's "40 questions" series that explores historical and foundational questions (questions 1-10), theological questions (questions 11-34), and contemporary and personal questions (questions 35-40).  It's a balanced, serious engagement from an evangelical (specifically Southern Baptist) who has spent decades researching and dialoguing with Roman Catholics.

Allison is clear that one of the fundamental differences between Roman Catholics and evangelicals generally is the approach of the relationship between nature and grace.  For Roman Catholics (cf. Question 3), nature and grace are intertwined.  Put simply, for Roman Catholics, nature transmits grace.  This is particularly true in the sacramental theology that infuses the Roman tradition.  While the sin of Adam may have corrupted nature, it did not obliterate the divine grace infused into it.  

Questions 11-13 will quite probably be the most interesting to readers.  There, Allison discusses the nature of Scripture and Tradition -- in particular, the Magisterium -- for Roman Catholics.  He discusses the way in which history, tradition and authority work together to create a unique theological perspective. 

Each question/chapter ends with a summary and then questions for reflection -- either for individual contemplation or group discussion.  The volume ends with a bibliography and a Scripture index.

This is one of the best discussions about the nature of Roman Catholic tradition that I've read from an evangelical perspective.  It's a strong contribution.

_______________________

I received a free copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for my honest review here.